Devalue, Delete, Revalue
Iraq's 1,500 proposal and the plan to delete the zeros came in one statement. We test the devalue, delete, revalue theory against the record.
UPDATE - Wednesday, October 7
After this briefing was produced, Iraq made the first move. The Council of Ministers approved a new rate in Tuesday's session and the Central Bank adopted it, effective today: 1,500 IQD to the dollar buying from the Finance Ministry, 1,510 selling to the banks, and 1,520 selling to the public.
Everything below, including the audio and the video, was produced while 1,500 was still a proposal. Read it with that in mind. The first step of the theory has now happened. The two that would follow it, the zeros and a higher rate, have not, and nothing in today's decision mentions either.
The test set out below still stands, and one part of it is already answered: the bank moved the rate itself. The street is the next thing to watch.
Wednesday, October 7. For the better part of this week one theory has been passed around the dinar community. Iraq lowers the IQD first, deletes the zeros, and only then raises the rate. Devalue, delete, revalue.
We saw it early and did not print it. On the first day it had one lawmaker and one leaked figure behind it, and we wanted to see what Baghdad itself would put on the record before handing it to you. On Monday and Tuesday we reported that nobody with authority over the rate had put a name to the number.
A reader wrote to us this week: "They sure are going back and forth with this." He is right. In 4 days Iraqis have been told that 150,000 is in the budget, that it will never be implemented, that it is subject to change, and that the zeros are postponed.
So today we stop following the headlines one at a time and lay the whole theory on the table. What has been said, who has the power to do each part of it, why a government would do it, and what would prove it wrong.
Reset Intelligence / Research Desk
Your deep research analyst.
Put any question on the IQD, the RV or the reset to the RI research assistant. It answers in seconds and will conduct deep research to find you the answer.
Try the Research AssistantTwo Proposals, One Statement
Safaa al-Jabiri sits on parliament's economy committee. Late on Monday he told Iraqi media:
"There is a proposal from the finance minister to adjust the official exchange rate to 150,000 dinars for every $100, but there is no final decision so far."
Most of the coverage stopped at that sentence. Al-Jabiri did not. In the same statement he went on to say changing Iraq's currency, and possibly deleting the zeros, is being discussed with high seriousness inside the Prime Minister's office and the Central Bank. What is holding it up, he said, is settling which authority has the legal power to approve it.
As regular readers know from A Budget for What Rate?, and for anyone new here, the rate is the Central Bank's to set. The currency is a separate job, and Iraq's law splits that one in two.
New banknotes belong to the Central Bank. Its governor, Nizar Nasser Hussein, said in September that redesigning the currency or issuing new denominations falls strictly under the bank's legal authority. Parliament's Finance Committee points to Article 36 of the Central Bank law for the same thing.
Deleting the zeros is the exception. The governor said it requires a law passed by parliament, because every contract, debt, fine and fee in Iraq is written in the current dinar and would have to be restated.
So the only step the bank cannot take alone is the one al-Jabiri says is stuck.
What Parliament Was Shown
On Tuesday Iraq's Finance Minister, Faleh al-Sari, sat with the Finance Committee, as the committee said he would. Afterwards one of its members, Abbas Hayal, gave the draft's figures to the Iraqi press.
Total spending of 217 trillion IQD. A deficit of 50 trillion. Oil priced at $58 a barrel. Exports of 4 million barrels a day. And an exchange rate of 1,500 IQD to the dollar.
A second committee member, Rebwar Karim, came out of the same meeting and told reporters that the 150,000 figure "is subject to change." A banking specialist in Iraq, Mustafa Hantush, described what is on the table as a range of 1,400 to 1,500, with no official approval issued.
Look hard at the oil line. An Iraqi oil expert, Hamza al-Jawaheri, called 4 million barrels a day "impossible." With the Strait of Hormuz shut, Iraq is exporting between 2 million and 2.25 million. With it open, he puts the ceiling near 3.5 million. A budget that counts on oil it cannot ship has to find the money somewhere else, and that makes the rate line carry more weight than it should.
And a delegation from the Kurdistan Region was in Baghdad this week pressing its own share of the same budget. The draft has cleared the government's economic council. It still has to pass the full cabinet and then parliament, which is owed it by October 15.
Why Lower It at All
This part is our analysis, built on what the Iraqis themselves have said the move is for.
The first reason is the two rates. We set out who lives off the gap between them in Iraq Refuses a Weaker Dinar. On Tuesday that gap reached about 32,000 IQD on every $100. Dilan Ghafoor, the lawmaker who first disclosed the figure, said its purpose is to narrow it. Move the bank's price toward the street and the margin shrinks.
Baghdad is squeezing the same trade from the other side. Since October 1 importers must pay their customs duties and tax deposits up front, through a licensed bank, before their payment abroad is released. Baghdad's Chamber of Commerce is already complaining about it. That is how you can tell it bites.
The second reason is the reserves. The country's foreign reserves stood at about $102 billion at the end of February and about $86 billion at the end of June. Nearly $16 billion went in 4 months, drawn down to pay state salaries while oil exports were choked. Salaries are paid in IQD. At 1,500, every dollar of oil income covers more of them, so the same payroll takes fewer dollars out of the vault. Ghafoor put the gain at about 20 trillion IQD a year.
Here the community's reading and ours meet. A widely read analyst in the dinar world argued this week that the reserves are what make a higher rate defensible in the first place. When the bank moves, the vault is what stops the market pushing it back. We agree with the logic. It also explains the order. You refill the vault before you make the promise the vault has to keep.
The third reason is the zeros. Taking them off changes the numbers on the notes, not what a dollar costs, so a street premium of 24 percent today is still 24 percent the morning after. Close the gap first and the new currency starts clean.
The same analyst put it bluntly when the figure first leaked. You "cannot delete three zeros while a parallel market is eating the official rate." A day later he added that closing the gap is the goal, and that getting there "doesn't have to involve devaluation." We carry both, because the second is the honest caveat on the first.
How Long Between the Steps
Iraq has made both moves before. In December 2020 the Central Bank took the dinar from 1,182 to 1,450. In February 2023 the bank set it back to 1,300, and the cabinet approved. The wait between them had a cause. In 2020 oil had collapsed, the state could not meet its payroll, and nothing else was ready.
That is not where Baghdad stands today. The state banks are under audit. The new notes are ordered, which we covered in Iraq Orders New Banknotes. Customs runs on an electronic system. The foreign military mission ended on September 30. The preparation that takes years is the part already behind it.
One number will be thrown at you, so here it is. Parliament's Finance Committee has said the full process of removing the zeros runs 3 to 7 years. That is the time it takes for old notes to leave circulation while both kinds are accepted side by side. It measures the note swap. It says nothing about the rate.
On the rate, this is our speculation. A rate changes by decision. In February 2023 the move to 1,300 was announced on a Tuesday and in force on the Wednesday. If the theory is right, nothing in the mechanics forces a long gap between the step down and the step up. We put no date on it, and neither has anyone with the authority to.
What Would Prove It Wrong
The theory has real weaknesses and you should have them.
The bank has not adopted it. On Monday a source inside the Central Bank told Kurdish media that the matter has not become an official decision and that the bank would clarify. No statement has followed on the bank's own site. In June the same bank called a circulating letter proposing 1,600 a forgery, and said so on the record. On 1,500 it has so far said only, through a source, that nothing is decided.
The money motive cuts the other way too. A finance ministry facing a 50 trillion deficit, with an oil line it cannot fill, has its own reason to want 20 trillion more. It would want that with or without a currency plan behind it.
The street has already run past the number. At more than 163,000, a step to 1,500 would not close the gap today. Hantush called this week's jump a bubble driven by rumor.
Then there is the claim that the zeros are off. On Tuesday an Iraqi economic commentator, Haider al-Sheikh, said the project has been postponed because the government is short of liquidity. He holds no office. In July the same man told the same outlet that the government was studying a currency change in order to boost liquidity, which we examined in Is Iraq Ready to Drop the Zeros? The cure in July has become the obstacle in October. The analyst we quoted above made the sharper point: replacing a currency does not spend the government's money, so a shortage of it is a strange reason to wait.
So here is how to tell. If the Central Bank announces the new rate itself, parliament takes up the law on the zeros, and the street gap starts to close, the theory is holding. If 1,500 turns up only as a line in a budget, with no law and the street still climbing, it was a deficit fix and nothing more.
The Street, the Weapons and the Chairs
Baghdad's two main exchanges, Al-Kifah and Al-Harithiya, finished Tuesday with $100 priced above 163,000 IQD. The morning price had been 159,800, and Monday's close 160,300. Exchange shops sold at 163,500 and bought at 162,500. Erbil sold at 162,850. The Central Bank's price is still 131,000.
On the weapons, there is movement. Iraq's Prime Minister, Ali al-Zaidi, told a gathering of tribal sheikhs that 5 armed factions have agreed to hand over their weapons and 3 have already done it. He gave no names. On Monday evening he also sat with the Coordination Framework's leaders, where a political source says he warned the parties with armed wings against failing their commitments. His deadline for bringing those weapons under the state is June 30, 2027.
At that same meeting he pressed the leaders to settle the vacant cabinet posts and hold the vote quickly.
Tehran and Washington
Trump said on Tuesday that his biggest problem with Iran is that "nobody knows" who is running the country. He was speaking at a shipyard event in Sparrows Point, Maryland. Tehran's foreign ministry answered that Washington knows exactly who it is dealing with.
In the Strait of Hormuz a projectile hit a Panamanian-flagged tanker and set it on fire. Oman's air force lifted 10 of the crew off. At least 12 of the 19 on board were hurt. Brent closed Tuesday near $100.80.
One Treasury item is worth your attention. On October 1 a senior Treasury official co-hosted a roundtable in New York that put Syria's finance minister and central bank governor in front of American banks. Its subject was reconnecting a cut-off central bank to the dollar system once its controls are judged good enough. That was the same day Bessent sat with Iraq's foreign minister to set out what Washington expects from al-Zaidi's reforms, a meeting we reported under Are Gold-Backed Currencies Coming?
The Read
On Tuesday, Iraqis paid 163,000 IQD for a hundred dollars. They were buying their way out of a currency their own government had just proposed to cut.
Follow those dollars, because what happens to them tells you which story this is.
Say the cut to 150,000 is all there is. A ministry short of cash takes the rate down and stops. The street keeps its distance from the bank, the dollar keeps climbing, and everyone who ran on Tuesday was right to run.
Now say the cut is the first move. Iraq's Central Bank steps to 150,000 and then closes the gap between its price and the one outside, which is what the new customs rules and the bank audits are aimed at. Then the street comes down to meet the bank. Anyone who paid 163,000 on Tuesday is now holding dollars worth 150,000. Then the zeros come off and the rate goes up, and the dinars they sold are worth more than the dollars they bought with them.
A step down that is followed by a step up does something an ordinary devaluation never does. It makes leaving the currency expensive. In our view an Iraq that wants its people to save in dinars instead of dollars has to teach that lesson at some point, and this is how it is taught.
Washington wants the same result. Since it tightened Iraq's dollar transfers in late 2022, its aim has been fewer dollars leaking out through the street.
Is this the plan? It is our theory. Nobody at the Central Bank of Iraq has said it, and we will not pretend otherwise. But the street will tell you before any minister does. If the dollar keeps running after a move to 150,000, the people who fled the dinar were right.
If it falls back toward the bank's price, the theory is working. And everyone who fled on Tuesday sold the currency this plan was built to lift.
Recent analysis
- Iraq Targets One Unified Exchange Rate
- Who Is Joining Iraq's Government?
- Why They Want the IQD Cut Reversed
- Baghdad Is Hiding the Date
- Iraq Goes First
Sources & References
- Update: Council of Ministers approves the new rate, Central Bank adopts 1,500 / 1,510 / 1,520 effective October 7 - Rudaw | The New Region | Shafaq News | Iraqi Media Network (Arabic)
- MP Safaa al-Jabiri: finance minister's proposal of 150,000 dinars per $100, "no final decision so far" - 964media
- Al-Jabiri on changing the currency and deleting zeros, under serious discussion in the Prime Minister's office and the Central Bank, held up by the question of which authority approves it - 964media (Arabic) | Iraqi News
- Central Bank governor Nizar Nasser Hussein: new designs and denominations are the bank's authority, deleting zeros requires legislation - Iraqi News
- Finance Committee on Article 36 of the Central Bank law, the laws a redenomination would amend, and a 3 to 7 year process - Channel8 | Channel8
- Draft 2027 budget after the Finance Committee met the finance minister: 217 trillion IQD, 50 trillion deficit, $58 oil, 4 million barrels a day, 1,500 per dollar, MP Abbas Hayal - Shafaq News
- Committee member Rebwar Karim: the 150,000 rate "is subject to change" - Channel8
- Banking specialist Mustafa Hantush: proposals of 1,400 to 1,500, no official approval, the street jump a bubble - 964media (Arabic)
- Oil expert Hamza al-Jawaheri: 4 million barrels a day "impossible", current exports 2 million to 2.25 million, about 3.5 million with the strait open - Shafaq News
- Kurdistan Region delegation in Baghdad for 2027 budget talks - Rudaw
- MP Dilan Ghafoor on the purpose of the figure and the 20 trillion in revenue; Central Bank source says it is not yet an official decision - Al-Mustaqila (Arabic) | Channel8
- Advance payment of customs duties and tax deposits from October 1, Baghdad Chamber of Commerce concerns - Shafaq News
- Iraq's reserves from about $102 billion on February 28 to about $86 billion at the end of June - AGBI
- Community analyst on reserves and a defensible rate, on the zeros and the parallel market, on closing the gap without devaluation, and on the liquidity argument - X | X | X | X
- Iraq's December 2020 devaluation from 1,182 to 1,450 and the February 2023 move to 1,300, approved by cabinet and in force the next day - The New Arab | Iraq Oil Report
- Central Bank calls a circulating 1,600 letter a forgery, June 17 - Iraqi News
- Economic commentator Haider al-Sheikh says the zeros proposal is postponed - Channel8 | His July account of a currency change to boost liquidity - Channel8
- Dollar closes Tuesday above 163,000 IQD in Baghdad, shops at 163,500, Erbil at 162,850 - Shafaq News
- Al-Zaidi to tribal sheikhs: 5 factions agreed to hand over weapons, 3 already have - SyriacPress
- Al-Zaidi presses Framework leaders on the cabinet vote and warns armed factions on the weapons deadline - Shafaq News
- Trump: "nobody knows" who is running Iran; Tehran's reply - Arab News
- Oman evacuates 10 crew from a Panamanian-flagged tanker hit in the Strait of Hormuz, at least 12 of 19 injured - Al Jazeera
- Brent near $100.80 - Trading Economics
- Treasury co-hosts Syrian banking roundtable, October 1 - US Treasury | Bessent meeting with Iraq's foreign minister - US Treasury
- Internal callbacks - A Budget for What Rate? | Iraq Refuses a Weaker Dinar | Iraq Orders New Banknotes | Is Iraq Ready to Drop the Zeros? | Are Gold-Backed Currencies Coming?
- The Two Tracks - How Dinar Holders Actually Get Paid
- The Research Desk - Ask the RI Research Assistant - it answers in seconds and will conduct deep research to find you the answer.
- The Library - Free Resource Library
- Book - Head of the Snake
- Common questions about the Iraqi dinar - Is the Iraqi dinar revaluation real? | When will the Iraqi dinar revalue? | What will the Iraqi dinar revalue at? | Is the Iraqi dinar a scam? | Why is the Iraqi dinar valued so low? | Where can I safely buy Iraqi dinar? | How do I exchange Iraqi dinar after a revaluation? | Will I owe tax when my dinar revalues?
For simple answers to every common question, see the full Iraqi Dinar FAQ.
This briefing was published 7 days ago for subscribers.
Members get every briefing the morning it drops. Subscribe to stay a week ahead.
READ IR-001 FREE
GET THE BOOK
SUBSCRIBE FROM $5/MO